Discover 20 Easy Weeknight Dinners for Busy Families ➔

Pastrami Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Katz Deli Pastrami Sandwich at Home

Pastrami Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Katz Deli Pastrami Sandwich at Home

Win a
$1,000 Milwaukee Tool Package

One DIY Projects subscriber wins on May 10. A full kit of Milwaukee tools — the kind that makes a weekend project easier to finish, whether it’s a fence post, a set of shelves, or the cabinet door that’s been sticking for years. Free entry, just an email.

Hosted by our partner site

diy-logo

Have you every wanted to sink your teeth into a Katz Deli Pastrami Sandwich? The tender, juicy pastrami, perfectly balanced mustard, and fresh rye bread all define this New York classic. But if you haven't been to Katz Deli or even New York for that matter, we've got you covered. Youtuber Alvin from Anything With Alvin shares the steps to recreate this legendary sandwich so you can enjoy it in the comfort of your home.

Pastrami Sandwich Recipe: How to Make the Iconic Katz Deli Pastrami Sandwich at Home

The Legend of Katz Deli

Because of its famous pastrami sandwiches, Katz Deli has become a must-visit spot in New York City. Locals and tourists flock to the deli for an authentic New York experience. The secret? Top-quality ingredients and old-school preparation. From the hand-carved pastrami to the fresh bread, everything is made to perfection.

How to Make the Perfect Katz Deli Pastrami Sandwich

Making a Katz Deli pastrami sandwich at home is easier than you might think. Let’s go through this detailed guide to recreating New York's legendary deli sandwich.

Ingredients

Creating an authentic Katz Deli pastrami sandwich starts with high-quality ingredients:

  • Beef Brisket: A good cut for a tender pastrami.
  • Spice Mix: A blend of coriander, black pepper, garlic, and paprika.
  • Rye Bread: A dense and chewy bread that can hold a hearty stack of pastrami.
  • Spicy Brown Mustard: Adds a tangy kick to enhance the flavor.
  • Pickles: Fermented cucumbers that provide a refreshing contrast.

Preparing the Pastrami

The star of any Katz Deli sandwich is the pastrami. Start by curing and smoking the beef brisket. Mix spices and herbs such as coriander, black pepper, garlic, and paprika. Rub the brisket with this mix and cure it for several days to helpthe flavors penetrate completely into the meat.

After curing, slowly smoke the brisket over low heat. This gives the pastrami its signature smoky flavor. Be patient—smoking takes time, but it’s worth the effort! You know you made the right decisionto wait the moment you end up with tender, flavorful pastrami.

Slicing the Pastrami

How you slice the pastrami makes a big difference in the sandwich. Use a hand-carving technique to cut the meat just right. Your slices should be thin enough to show your pastrami’s tenderness but still thick enough to hold the sandwich together. Achieving this perfect slice is the key to a satisfying bite every time.

Bread and Condiments

Choosing the right bread and condiments is just as important as the pastrami. For best results, go with a dense, chewy rye bread. It should be sturdy enough to support all the pastrami you want.

Katz Deli pickle

Meanwhile, the condiment of choice is spicy brown mustard. Spread a generous amount on both slices of rye bread to enhances the pastrami’s flavor without overwhelming it.

Assembling the Pastrami Sandwich

Finally, it’s time to put everything together. Pile the hand-carved pastrami high between the two slices of rye bread. Remember, don’t hold back—these sandwiches are known for being generously stuffed.

Gently press the sandwich so the flavors can meld together. For an authentic touch, serve with pickles. Their tangy crunch adds a refreshing contrast to the rich, smoky pastrami.

Tips and Tricks

Try these several tips and tricks to ensure your pastrami sandwich turns out just right:

Pastrami Sandwich Recipe

  • Quality Ingredients: Choose high-quality beef brisket and rye bread. After all, these ingredients directly impact the flavor and texture of your pastrami sandwich.
  • Patience: Let the curing and smoking process take its time. In fact, slow curing and smoking bring out the best in the meat.
  • Hand-Carving: Hand-carve the pastrami yourself so you can achieve the perfect thickness for every slice.
  • Generous Portions: Pile on the pastrami. Katz Deli sandwiches are famous for their generous portions, so make sure your pastrami sandwich is well-stuffed.

Bringing Katz Deli to Your Kitchen

Recreating the famous Katz Deli’s sandwiches is a meaty labor of love. Even better, the results will undeniably be worth it. Enjoy this iconic culinary experience without booking a trip to New York. So, gather your ingredients, fire your smoker, and embark on this delicious journey. Happy cooking!

Craving more kitchen secrets? Click the link for more tips on perfecting your pastrami sandwich and other iconic recipes you can make at home!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tested recipes built around what's already in your pantry, now in your inbox.

Turn Your Inbox Into A Recipe Box

Keep in touch for the latest recipes, tips and more!

Win a
$1,000 Milwaukee Tool Package

 One DIY Projects subscriber wins May 10. Free to enter. Approximately $1,000 in Milwaukee branded products, shipped via Amazon.com.

Hosted by our partner site

diy-logo

Popular This Week

Calling All Cooks! We Want You! Click here to contribute!

Related Recipes

Scroll to Top